double chocolate chip muffins

Something I joke about when introducing a new muffin recipe (not this one!) in my new cookbook out this fall is the gap between the muffins we gaze at in a coffee shop case and those we make at home. Why is one towering, glossy and plush and the ones I make for breakfast so… beige? I mean, I do know. When I’m the one baking the muffins, I balk at all of the refined sugar, flour, and oil needed to make them that pretty. So I stuff them with oats and dried fruit and whole-grain everything and then yes, they’re heavy and beige. But as I was staring at these beauties at my local bagel shop the other morning, I decided: enough.

double chocolate chip muffins-1double chocolate chip muffins-2

Sometimes you need a chocolate muffin that’s hardly even pretending that it’s not just cake. Sure, it’s got yogurt in it. Sure, the sweetness is held in check. But I decided that I needed a recipe in my repertoire for a chocolate muffin as pretty as I’m tempted to buy for the days only a dark chocolate muffin will do. It was a very good idea; not a single person in my family has minded as I tested and retested these to get them exactly right for us. They fit all of my baking rules: they’re one-bowl, use no fussy ingredients, and even pass the left-it-out-on-the-counter-overnight test. The muffins are still shockingly plush (even if, of course, a touch more dry) in the morning. Finally, you can reduce your commitment level easily: halved, it makes six muffins. I hope they set your week off perfectly.

double chocolate chip muffins-5
double chocolate chip muffins-4


6 months ago: Fall Bliss Salad and Cranberry Pecan Bread
1 year ago: Classic Shortbread, Quick, Easy Salsa, and Twisty Cinnamon Buns
2 year ago: Rhubarb Cordial
3 year ago: Braised Ginger Meatballs In Coconut Broth
4 years ago: Triple Coconut Cream Pie
5 years ago: Pistachio Cake and A Reall Great Pot of Chickpeas
6 years ago: Potato Pizza, Even Better, Carrot Tahini Muffins and Sheet Pan Chicken Tikka
7 years ago: Strawberry Rhubarb Soda Syrup, Artichoke Gratin Toasts and Maple Pudding Cake
8 years ago: Lamb Meatballs with Feta and Lemon
9 years ago: Ramp Pizza and Yogurt Panna Cotta with Walnuts and Honey
10 years ago: Pasta with Garlicky Broccoli Rabe, Classic Ice Cream Sandwiches and Cinnamon Toast French Toast
11 years ago: Heavenly Chocolate Cake Roll and Crispy Potato Roast
12 years ago: Tangy Spiced Brisket
13 years ago: Pickled Grapes with Cinnamon and Black Pepper and Buttermilk Ice Cream
14 years ago: Fork-Crushed Purple Potatoes, Whole Wheat Apple Muffins, and Caramelized Shallots
15 years ago: Black Bean Confetti Salad and Margarita Cookies and Tequila Lime Chicken

Double Chocolate Chip Muffins

  • Servings: 12
  • Source: Smitten Kitchen
  • Print

There is a lot of ingredient flexibility here, too. You can use any oil you like to bake with or butter. You can use non-dairy milk, or even coffee or water for the milk. You can use a thicker Greek yogurt or a “regular” one, though I prefer the latter here. You can use white or raw sugar instead, but if you’re choosing one, I love brown sugar the most with chocolate cakes. Any kind of cocoa powder will work; I tested this with both Hershey’s Dark and Valrhona (a Dutched cocoa) and both were dreamy. The chocolate chips, however, are not optional.

  • 1/2 cup (100 to 115 grams) oil or melted butter
  • 2/3 cup (140 grams) light or dark brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup (120 grams) milk, any kind
  • 1 cup (225 grams) plain yogurt
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 3/4 cup (60 grams) cocoa powder, any kind
  • 1 3/4 cups (230 grams) flour
  • 1 1/3 cups (225 grams) chocolate chips, divided

Heat oven to 350°F. Either coat a 12-cup standard muffin tin with butter or nonstick spray, or line with paper liners. In a large bowl, whisk together the butter, sugar, milk, yogurt, and vanilla. Whisk in eggs. Sprinkle salt and baking soda over the batter and whisk thoroughly to combine. Stir in cocoa powder, whisking until any lumps disappear. Stir in flour and 1 cup of the chocolate chips.

Spoon the batter into the 12 muffin cups; don’t fret if it goes all the way to the top. Scatter the remaining 1/3 cup chips over the tops of the muffins. Bake muffins for 18 to 20 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center of each muffin comes out batter-free.

Eat right away or store muffins a few days in an airtight container at room temperature. Muffins get a bit more dry each day that they rest, but will rewarm nicely.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

New here? You might want to check out the comment guidelines before chiming in.

144 comments on double chocolate chip muffins

  1. Maura

    I just love you. You consistently amaze me with your taste, skills and expressions. In a time of major upheaval, disappointments and craziness, coming to you is such a balm for my soul.
    And then to post a chocolate muffin! Oh the glory! Thank you!

  2. Susan S

    I have been looking for a recipe like this! So, why do I want to insert little balls of ganche into the center before baking? Maybe I’d have to bake them in XL bakery sized muffin tins? Hmmm….can’t wait to try it!

      1. Elisabeth Hardcastle

        Cool, I was thinking 3/4 cup almond the rest reg. flour so if I make this for the kids…a little substance. Thanks Deb-I can’t tell you how many of your recipes I use in my daily rotation!

    1. Jennifer

      I subbed all almond flour and could have used a touch less, but they baked up perfectly anyway. I used 230g and next time I will use 200g.

  3. Emily L

    Just got these in the oven for my chocolate obsessed 6 year old (ok, and me too)! I didn’t have any plain yogurt or sour cream, but in the spirit of the recipe, I used this slightly weird tasting cookies and cream Greek yogurt that wasn’t exactly loved by our family. So far, the batter is tasty, ha! I think what I loved the most about this recipe is the very, very few dishes it took to make it and the flexibility of ingredients. Definitely going to be my “in a pinch chocolate fix” I think from now on!

  4. Bentley

    I have been hoping you would do a chocolate chocolate chip muffin recipe for a very very long time. In high school many years ago we could buy a Costco muffin for a $1 and I always chose chocolate chip. I have tried to recreate them many times – because I am too old to eat 3x the muffin I really should once a week – and they always fail my memory’s standards. Nostalgia AND pants that still fit – you are a fantastic Deb!

    1. Bentley

      Doubling back to confirm that these exactly as written are , indeed, perfection. I had concerns about the batter overflowing but they just domed gorgeously. My children declared them better than Costco’s. Now if I just could get back my high school energy level I’d be set! Will be trying these with coffee and buttermilk very very soon in the meantime!

    1. deb

      I didn’t test this with buttermilk instead of yogurt and milk, but wish I had (milk and yogurt seemed more breakfast-y). I suspect it will be okay, but report back if you can, thanks.

        1. I was JUST telling my husband I wanted to try something new for breakfast and then a friend sent me this post. Definitely trying them soon. Thank you!

  5. Cyndi

    Oh I can’t wait to make these just as they are. I have everything in my kitchen to make them! Double chocolate! No mixer! One bowl! What more could anyone ask for? This is the best cooking blog out there, bar none. I don’t even think I’d mind if Smitten Kitchen was the ONLY one!

      1. Angie

        I have everything except the yogurt. I’ve been putting off going to the store to get more.. guess I have a good reason to go now!

  6. Allison

    So I may have just made these tonight, even though I had plans of using the rhubarb I had just bought to make the rhubarb snacking cake. I halved the recipe and they have turned out delish! Used Greek yogurt, not too sweet, very chocolatey. Will be making again!

  7. Giorgiana

    Can I use buttermilk in this? And if yes, to replace the milk or the yogurt? Can’t wait to try. So many of your recipes are in my heavy rotation! Thank you :)

      1. Debbie Smith

        Easy, quick, yummy! They are lighter and far less sweet than a typical dense, heavier chocolate cupcake from a bakery. I used Hershey’s espresso chocolate chips on top – just the right amount of coffee flavor.

    1. deb

      I’d think so (although I’d bump the sugar to 1 cup for more of a cake taste). I’m not sure how long it would bake but I would check it at 35 minutes, then every 5 thereafter. It will probably be 3/4 full.

  8. Lori

    Any suggestions for subbing something non-dairy for the yogurt? Or just use a different recipe completely? Thanks.

    1. MCP

      I love the double chocolate banana bread recipe on this site as muffins. One recipe makes 12 muffins. I make it dairy-free by using oil in place of the melted butter. A staple recipe in our home.

  9. Maro

    made, cooled, sampled!

    i used the Guittard bittersweet and milk chips mixed, and the top had just the (kind of giant!) milk chips placed on top and OMG they look like brown cartoon mushrooms and taste amazing!

    i’m so happy with these, and certain i will cry when the half-batch i made is gone (tomorrow?!)

  10. Erica B

    Made these tonight & they came out a bit flat in flavour (though not flat in rise, they look great!). Maybe I was cheap on the salt. So don’t do as I did, pay attention to the salt.

  11. Camille

    Haha same here Deb! I start to bake muffins at home…”2/3 cup sugar? Could I maybe do 1/2 instead? And what if I use whole wheat pastry flour? Stick in some walnuts, why not…” What I end up with is a perfectly good breakfast, but NOT an indulgence. You’ve inspired me to let it all loose on this one.

  12. I will definitely be trying these ones, but admit that I will use at least some oat flour, just to see what happens (my husband will eat pretty much anything I bake, even if it doesn’t quite work)…but I know what you mean – life is too short not indulge from time to time!

    Also – I will ensure the library where I work orders a copy of your forthcoming book :) And I imagine one will make its way to my personal library as well!

  13. Amy

    These look amazing. If I added a
    Banana, would I have to make other adjustments in the recipe? Maybe reduce the amount of yogurt?

    1. deb

      I’d swap mashed banana for the yogurt, however, you might get less of a rise if you’re using a Dutched cocoa (European-style) and no acidic ingredient (what the yogurt is). In that case, I’d swap the milk for buttermilk and hopefully it does the trick.

      1. Jennifer Gieber

        I didn’t have yogurt on hand, but had plenty of bananas, so decided to give this a try and they are delicious! I added a some white vinegar for acidity (1 tablespoon I think).

  14. Katie

    I SO appreciate and understand this argument!!! What beautiful muffins! Thank you <3 they are just what we need right now

  15. Cassie

    I homeschool my kids and every year our reward for getting it done is to make a big batch of whoopie pies. It’s hot here this week and honestly my stamina for pulling out sheet after sheet of cookie halves is never very high on a normal day, but right now is at an all-time low after pandemic-ing and working third shift, so I decided to make these instead as an attempt to lighten my own load. They are, honestly, incredible. They look incredible, they taste incredible, I didn’t have to get in my car and drive to our coffee shop and wait in line and spend five bucks for one of them. So much to love. I just threw it all together and 40 minutes later I’m in heaven and so are all three of my kids. THANK. YOU.

  16. Dee

    Beautiful!! My muffins never really create a pretty top dome that “overhangs” the sides of the liner like this. Is the problem just not filling the muffin cups enough, or could it be a rising issue related to my leavener or oven temp?

  17. Camille Lozeron

    Hi Deb!
    This looks divine. I love your muffins. What type of chocolate chips do you recommend? Bittersweet? Semi-sweet? Can’t wait to try!

    1. deb

      I use semi-sweet here but either work (and I don’t think there are technical rules for labels of each term, so it might not mean much which you choose).

  18. Sara

    What will be the major difference in using melted butter or canola oil? Aside from one being dairy free, is there a difference with texture?

      1. Cy

        I agree with you about butter and flavor.Lately if a recipe calls for oil I’ve been using avocado oil and I think it really adds a creamy aspect that other oils don’t. Also because of it’s high heat point it keeps more of the nutritional value than other oils can lose.
        Note: in his book Eat Smarter Sawn Stevenson explained the latest research on the healthiest fats to eat and cook with. Thanks again Deb for another “have to try” recipe. I plan to whip some up tomorrow morning!

  19. Kara

    Made these yesterday and used what I had on hand which was: white whole wheat flour, almond milk, canola oil. I added a tablespoon of coffee because it was there. I forgot to put the chocolate chips on top and messed up the oven temp a little (went too low so had to bake for about 5 extra minutes). And they turned out great! Exactly what you described them to be, Deb! I like them better on day 2…yes they’re technically drier but not dry at all, more muffin-y now in my opinion (vs. cupcake-y). And the tops! Soooo good, I can only imagine how much better they’d be if I hadn’t forgotten the chocolate chips on top. Very easy recipe.

  20. Beverly

    I seen this Recipe and just had to make them. Love them and hubby likes them too. Thank you! I had to use sour cream as I did not have yogurt but they turned out great.

  21. Rebecca

    Made these today and subbed coffee for the milk and used buttermilk instead of yogurt. Delicious! Made 12 larger muffins and 16 mini muffins. My kids are currently running the mini muffins through a container of cool whip for an after school snack. 🙈

  22. Lynn

    Halved the recipe and made 6, because I’ll eat all 12 in a couple days otherwise.

    Subbed sour cream and coconut milk (not the canned kind) for yogurt and milk, as that’s what I had on hand.

    They’re just perfect and so easy to make, they’re dangerous!

      1. Kate

        I made this in a loaf pan and it turned out great. Took about an hour with lots of checking at the end. Swapped the milk for strong coffee because I like coffee. Tastes great and goes excellent with milk or coffee or orange juice. Chocolate in the morning, what’s not to like?

  23. Barb

    I recall reading about using espresso or coffee to enhance chocolate baking. Would you recommend this? Is it powdered or brewed coffee and how would I incorporate it into the recipe?

    1. Yael

      She says in the recipe notes that you can sub the milk for brewed coffee. If you still want to use the milk, I don’t see a reason not to use powdered coffee – depending on what kind, you can mix it into either the dry ingredients or the wet (at home I only have freeze-dry instant coffee, which comes in largish granules, so I’d make sure to mix it into the wet ingredients until all melted, otherwise it might not incorporate well; from what I understand, espresso powder is more finely ground so you could mix it into the flour like any other spice).

  24. Angie A.

    These are wonderful, and I’m going to share them with the students in my summer class today. I only had 60% bittersweet chips on hand, but I think next time I’ll try milk chocolate, or even perhaps a mix of semisweet and peanut butter chips for a pop of sweetness.

  25. Yael

    Oh this is going to happen here. And soon.
    Although… well, I know you said the chocolate chips are not optional, but I still have a bag of butterscotch chips I bought on a visit to the US last summer and want to use in something. These might turn into chocolate butterscotch muffins.

    (I also really want to try switching the yoghurt with sour cream, because that often works really well, but as it happens I currently have only the former and not the latter.)

  26. Anna McLoon

    I love muffins for sure, but what does plush mean when applied to baked goods? You use that adjective with nearly every recipe for baked goods, and yet I can’t find a definition of plush that applies to baked goods so am trying to figure out what you are trying to describe so I know if I should try this recipe. Thanks.

    1. deb

      I’m thinking thick and cushiony. Plush is often a soft fabric but it’s come to mean something more richly luxurious. Anyway, think: soft but thick.

  27. Brenda P Boyd

    Excellent recipe. Made as written. I opted for veg oil, light brown sugar, and coffee with full-fat greek yogurt. I used Aldi Dark Chocolate Morsels. Beautiful recipe. I love your “non-fussy” one-bowl recipes. Easy-Peasy. Thanks for sharing.

  28. Tonya

    Baked these today. Mine came out very bittersweet. They will need a scoop of ice cream and raspberries to fix them…..

  29. Shelley Levine

    I’d like to make these in mini muffin form. Any cautions or thoughts? I was considering using mini chocolate chips for distribution issues.
    Love all your recipes, Deb! Thank you!

    1. deb

      I think mini-chips are a great idea and I wouldn’t expect any issues from mini-muffins. Just take them out as soon as they’re done.

    1. Susan

      I used fat free yogurt (what I had and had to them NOW) and coffee for the liquid. Delish. Maybe drier than if a higher fat used—but enough chips to not notice!

  30. Susan

    Do you think marscapone would work as a swap for yogurt here? (I have some left from last week’s mushroom pasta :) )

  31. Ann

    Made these this afternoon. If you, like me, are doubling the recipe, wildly multitasking, and constantly running up and down the basement stairs to get additional ingredients when you seem to be running out of everything in the cupboard, you can still make these in an hour and ten minutes. :)

    I ran out of ap flour so about a third of the flour was pastry flour – fantastic, still very plush. I used a mixture of semisweet and bittersweet chocolate chips in the batter. After tasting the batter, to add a little more sweetness I only topped each with a single white chocolate “melting chip” (they’re a bit larger). Not bad, looked pretty, not a huge difference in flavor. Would be fun to try a mini marshmallow instead, I think.

    I might’ve screwed up the salt – I was thinking kosher salt is saltier than table salt, but it’s probably the other way round, so I didn’t use enough table salt. I found these to be delicious albeit somewhat understated, despite all the chocolate; probably my salt error that’s the culprit. Looking forward to trying them again! Thank you Deb!

  32. Nikki

    These muffins are excellent!
    They do not taste like cupcakes disguised as muffins; the amount of sugar (I used brown sugar, as recommended) is just right.
    I made 24 muffins using 1.5 x the recipe. They’re not quite as towering as the pictures, but I was afraid of the tops sticking to my muffin pans and then having to fight to get them out.
    If anyone is curious about making them dairy free: I used df margarine and a little oil for the fat, almond milk, unsweetened coconut yogurt, and Enjoy Life chocolate chips.
    This recipe is a keeper!

  33. Jane

    I know the basic difference between a cupcake and a muffin, in terms of texture, leavening, mixing and ingredients, etc. That said, how different does this really taste compared to a chocolate cupcake? It sounds so delicious…so we just call it a muffin so it will sound like a healthier breakfast than a cupcake? (wink, wink)

  34. Pam. B

    These are delicious and so moist!
    I love how they’re not overly sweet. I used a combination of bittersweet and semisweet chocolate chips. The chocolate chips melt while you’re eating these muffins, I will definitely make these again.
    Thanks for an excellent recipe!

  35. Ellen

    What a great recipe! I made these with 1% Lactaid milk and as I didn’t have a full cup of yogurt I used applesauce to bring it up to a cup. I also used Hershey’s Dark Cocoa. The next time I make the recipe I’ll use non-stick spray instead of paper liners – I don’t want to waste a morsel! I love that you’re so open to people trying all sorts of variations. It’s a fantastic basic recipe and I don’t think it’s possible to ruin it.

  36. Cy

    Super excited to bake these. My go to is usually the Nigella Lawson recipe from her domestic goddess cookbook and they are very good, but I like your less sugar, add yogurt idea. I do recommend to you and anyone here to split your muffin ( perhaps lightly toast) and spread some peanut butter on it before devouring. You will not be sorry. :)

  37. Oh those look good and I’m sure they taste great! I’m going to scale it back for a smaller batch because I know I’d eat ALL of these. I see someone already asked about the sour cream so will try both ways.

  38. Thea

    Made these today, some with milk chocolate, some with dark chocolate and some with peanut butter chips. Consensus is that they’re all delicious!

    Also I finally got a copy of your second cookbook and am enjoying pouring over all of these delicious looking recipes. Can’t wait to get cooking!

  39. Claire

    Our local airport has a restaurant (yes, one restaurant) that makes amazing double chocolate muffins. My husband travels for work frequently and knows to always bring one home for me. I made this recipe this weekend (used avocado oil and almond milk to feel marginally better about it) and now he’s relieved of this duty! Thanks for another delicious, easy hit.

  40. Rachel

    These are absolute perfection! Bakery quality (love the height and glossiness), super quick and easy (even with my kids “helping”) and very few dishes (especially when using a kitchen scale). A winner!

  41. Robin

    These will be getting made as written and also subbing in peanut butter chips mmmm…. Maybe even a combo. Can’t wait to try them!!!

    1. Robin

      Made this this morning with espresso chips because another person mentioned and I was like genius as I have these chips in the house and was waiting for the perfect recipe to use them and this was definitely it! These are wonderful and rose nicely.
      My only issue/question is, I used paper liners and there was a pool of “grease” at the bottom when I went to remove them from the muffin tins. I waited 10 minutes for them to cool in the tins and then removed. They were not greasy to eat and for us perfect sweetness. I used one stick of Trader Joe’s unsalted butter. Was just curious if anyone else had this issue.

  42. Jesse

    Delicious! I used vanilla skyr and used a little less vanilla extract — wish I’d gone full vanilla, as I don’t think the flavor came through. But still wonderful!

  43. Lynn

    Just made this today. Halved recipe which made 16 mini muffins. The metric measurements were so helpful. Also used mini chocolate chips, so good! Perfectly moist and chocolatey, baked in 18 minutes.

  44. Lynda Handley

    I’m sorry but don’t think they’re sweet enough. Also had to add an extra egg and milk because the batter was too thick.

  45. Becky

    Thoughts on freezing muffins after they’ve baked and cooled? How would the taste hold up after defrosting and would defrosting mean just taking it out leaving it on the counter to come to room temp? Thanks!

  46. Meghan

    I made these following the recipe to the t except I didn’t have enough chocolate chips.
    Don’t skip them! Wish I had put in some other chocolate because they were kind of bland where there wasn’t any chocolate chip. Used Hersheys dark chocolate and the whole amount of kosher salt. So a little sad

  47. Nadine

    So delicious! I accidentally upped the milk to 2/3 cup, and they came out fabulous! I made my second batch the next day, making only half a batch, and cut the sugar back to 1/4 cup. Big mistake. Keep sugar where it is. Once again, you’ve given us a deliciously simple recipe, Deb. Thank you!

  48. Not only I spent way too much time starring at how perfect these double chocolate chip muffins look but I also ended up reading all the comments. I saw someone mention that these aren’t sweet enough so I’m excited to make this dessert because to me it seems like the perfect recipe. The pictures look decadent!

  49. Hayley

    Made these this morning with two ripe bananas instead of the two eggs (I have no issue with eggs, but I did have two extremely spotty bananas staring at me from the kitchen counter) and they turned out wonderfully! Yes, Deb has several other wonderful chocolate banana bread recipes on the site, but I wanted to be part of the double chocolate chip muffin zeitgeist! I also used about 45g fewer chips than called for because I didn’t feel like opening and chopping a new chocolate bar, and the muffins *are* lacking from the loss, but only a very wee bit. Off to eat seconds. :)

  50. Jane

    For anyone wondering this worked fine as mini muffins just shortened the cooking time a little – ymmv. used greek yogurt and it made the batter pretty thick so had to add more almond milk to loosen.

  51. Beverly

    Delicious! Due to an egg allergy in our family, I split the batter in half and used 1/4 cup applesauce in place of one egg (so, if doing the whole recipe, 1/2 c in place of the two eggs) and both versions came out perfect!!

  52. Jennifer B

    Made these yesterday and they turned out perfectly! I didn’t have yogurt but subbed in sour cream. This will stay in the rotation. Used semi sweet and espresso chips. Love the flexibility of the recipe.

  53. MadBenLove

    How do you feel about using sour cream for the yogurt (it’s what I have in the house) and making 24 mini muffins (I need to feed a crowd)?

  54. Vicki Salyer

    What kind of flour do I use? I am learning to bake at 65! I have bread flour, self-rising, and wheat flour. I am making these ASAP!

  55. Sara

    I actually wish these were sweeter, and I don’t usually say that about baked goods. I know they’re still meant to be “breakfast” but if we can call donuts & cinnamon rolls breakfast, I think we can go sweeter on the muffin front here (it’s already double chocolate, after all!) Not sure if I’ll make these again (they were very quick & easy so thay was nice) but if I did, I would up the sugar for sure.

  56. Nicky B

    Hey! Long-time fan, first-time commenter here. I’m so excited to make these muffins tomorrow morning, but the only muffin tin in my house is a JUMBO 6-muffin pan (I think by Wilton?).
    I presume I can just pop about 50% more batter in each of the muffin cups and then give it an extra 5 to 10 minutes in the oven at 350°F – but I was just curious if you or anyone else in the comments section had any more specific advice/tips to impart so I don’t end up criminally under- or overbaking. Thank you!!

  57. Judith

    These are amazing! We used avocado oil, coffee, sour cream and half Hershey’s regular cocoa and half Dutch processed cocoa. Thanks for sharing another wonderful recipe!

    1. Aurora Gandara

      You would not know that there was zucchini in it and they would probably be more moist. Have you made her zucchini bread as muffins? They are excellent and freeze so well for lunches.

  58. JP

    I used most of the same ingredients Deb suggested except I used 1 cup of white sugar in the batter to make it a bit sweeter, 1/2 cup of applesauce and 1/4 cup each sour cream and yogurt. I cut back a bit on the chocolate chips using 2/3 cup in the batter and 1/3 cup on top. They taste delicious. My question is about the silicone muffin pan I used. I actually love this pan because it does not need to be greased and the muffins come out easily with no waste. However, the muffins did not dome as much as I had hoped and took longer to bake by 7 minutes. They do not brown on the outsides much. This seems like a common problem with this sort of pan. Some muffin recipes seem to be fine, others, not quite right. The advantages to this pan are so great I wish I had no problems with it. Do you ever use a pan like this? Thanks!

    1. Ann

      I made a double batch, using one silicone muffin pan and one metal pan. I had the same issue with the muffins in the silicone pan not doming. The ones in the metal pan domed beautifully. No idea why this happens but wanted to offer solidarity. :)

  59. Monty

    I love the flexibility of this recipe! Since I was using whole wheat flour, I lowered it to 215 grams. I also used about a cup of sour cream (minus a few tablespoons) and whole coffee milk and they came out delicious!

  60. Lidia Villalva

    Made these immediately after seeing them on Instagram. They turned out picture perfect but unfortunately they were a bit dry and not sweet enough.

  61. Aurora Gandara

    I was going to make Ina’s raspberry bars tonight but she’s been preempted.
    These look deluxe and I have everything at home.

  62. Heather

    tl;dr: increase the salt!!

    I had a similar experience to a couple of other commenters and found that the flavor fell a bit flat. I followed Deb’s recipe to the gram and everything about this muffin is delectable (the incredibly plush interior! the chocolate-studded lid!) but it’s as if the potential of incredible chocolate flavor is held back. I appreciate that Deb keeps the sweetness in check, but maybe these need a bit more sugar to really let the chocolate flavor sing? Or just increasing the salt to 3/4 tsp might do the trick. Next time I think I’ll try both.

  63. Ali

    I can’t believe how delicious these are! I made normal chocolate chip muffins yesterday and tried these today – very decadent!

  64. Sydni

    Mine came out just okay – pretty dry, but they have potential. Next time, I’ll try with oil instead of butter, take them out two minutes earlier and ignore the fudgy batter that comes out with the toothpick, and mix with a stand mixer instead of by hand. Hopefully that will all make a little difference, but I’ll report back…

  65. Jackie

    Have these baking now, used butter, sour cream and King Arthur Black Cocoa (in for a penny, in for a pound). If the batter is any indication – YUM!!! Looks as though this may end up being in steady rotation, very simple, quick and delicious. Thank you!!

  66. After reading some of the comments, I went ahead and made this with buttermilk subbed for the yogurt and milk because that’s what I had on hand. Followed the recipe otherwise. Wanted to just offer a note for others that the muffins were delicious but did take ~6 minutes longer with this substitution; I think it made the batter a bit thinner than it would have been otherwise. Will definitely be making these again, hopefully with the yogurt on hand next time :)

  67. David H Miller

    The first Smitten Kitchen recipe I tried was double chocolate banana bread and it was so good I am pretty certain this will also be great.

  68. Sylvie

    The oven was on for another baked good so I stirred together a half batch of these. While warm I did a taste test, definitely a muffin – not a cupcake! I did a quick tally, a rough estimate, of the calories. Not sure they’re worth the 310+ but maybe they will be better when not quite so warm. For the record I used milk chocolate morsels.

  69. Becky

    Completely impressed by the texture of the muffin and how easy it is to make.

    Regarding the taste it’s important to remember it’s a muffin and not an indulgent dessert. My first bites were flavor-wise disappointing, just lacking oomph. When I reminded myself that it wasn’t meant to be an all-consuming cupcake, and adapted my mindset to it as a breakfast snack, then the flavor improved vastly.

    My recipe choices were 50/50 sunflower oil and melted butter, 50/50 leftover coffee and whole milk for the liquid, and a thick greek yogurt because that’s what was in the fridge

    It’s worthwhile to make and to consider how to notch up the depth in the future.

    Thanks for the recipe! Texture seriously awesome.

  70. Shweta

    Hi Deb and the SK universe…Since the recipe was published last week, I’ve made and personally eaten 2 batches of these! I love many of your recipes and am a dedicated, albeit quiet, fan. The first time I used Bob’s red mill egg replacer and some Kite Hill protein yogurt, and they were somewhat oddly thick/strangely textured but still good. Only when I baked the second batch as soon as I ate the last muffin did I realize I’d also skimped on the sugar by accident the first time. Take two, I used eggs and the suggested amount of sugar with half plain coconut yogurt and half Vegannaise because I ran out of yogurt. Cut the salt by half to account for the salt in the mayo. Yum! Catch me baking a third batch soon… 😉

  71. Naomi

    I just made these, hoping they’d be like the supersized double chocolate Costco muffins that my son loves! I didn’t have a tub of yogurt so I used three small vanilla yogurt cups (equivalent to 1 Cup) and skipped the vanilla. The batter GENEROUSLY filled 12 muffins, so they needed about 24 minutes to bake. Success…kid approved! (Just don’t tell him I omitted the 1/3 Cup chips sprinkled on top!)